Will & Co. Cafe

Reviews

• Tracy M.

  star star star star star 11 June 2026

  Here for a weekend get-a-way and our first time.  
  
  Inside is charming and clean.  Staff is very friendly and service was great.  Prices reasonable
  
  We are vegetarians and there was plenty of unique dishes for us to enjoy.
  
  Coffee is excellent - Cinnsation cold brew =yum
  
  Boyfriend said 'it's just plain awesome, home style and healthy'
  
  I ordered the southern bell minus Canadian bacon, He ordered avocado toast with a side of hollandaise and we shared sides of veggie hash and pumpkin French toast- all dishes were amazing and plates were clean for sure!

• Tipper P.

  star star star star star_border 7 June 2026

  Good atmosphere and very quick service.
  
  Eggs Benedict was pedestrian but the home fries were wonderful.
  
  The veggie quiche was good - but the cheese melted on top was unnecessary and distracting from the fresh veggies.
  
  The cornbread was good and the strawberry preserve was #lebomb

• Darlene M.

  star star star star_border star_border 31 May 2026

  The good, the bad, the ugly (from Austin TX):
  
  Good: -(honestly there's a lot of good here). Great location, friendly waitstaff and hostesses, cute cozy ambiance. Fantastic coffee-no lie!  Great flavor and seasonings in everything.
  
  Bad (ish): My husband and I each had the Mayflower Benedict- lobster and steak (one of each) with skillet potatoes and baked beans. The food had good flavor. While it is a good idea in theory, to put it on a croissant instead of an English muffin, unfortunately with the hollandaise sauce oozing down, it fails to hold up to it and became mushy. However a nice hollandaise sauce; we were offered extra and accepted!  The skillet potatoes were seasoned nicely but were a little too wet and mushy. For my taste. No "skillet" or "home-fried" to it. Maybe that's just how it's done here?  The baked beans were undercooked.  The lobster and steak: lobster was average, tad bit rubbery with little flavor. The steak tips were cooked correctly as ordered (medium rare) but were just...well...steak tips. I guess you can't expect much from tips.
  
  Ugly: I stopped eating my dish after crunching down on a piece of lobster shell, followed by taking a bite out of the poached egg and crunching down on an eggshell and lastly, back to a bite of the lobster, hitting shell once more. I figured God was trying to tell me to cut back on the calories or something.
  
  So I was rather disappointed by our findings after I looked to Yelp to lead/guide me. Hope the rest of you who dare to try it have a different experience

• Tim B.

  star star star star star_border 15 May 2026

  Great place for breakfast in Plymouth!  We had some hash, some vegan bowls with Quinoa and one with eggs.  Service was very good and the ambiance was nice.  It was crowded with people waiting on the sidewalk as late as 11 am but they moved the people through at a reasonable but unrushed pace.  I wanted to try the Mayflower with lobster and steak tips etc. but opted for the hash and eggs which was pretty good.  The others loved their bowls.  Coffee came around often enough (very important!) and tasted fine.  We walked but there was decent street parking available.  Prices were reasonable.
  This is a great town with lots of excellent dining options.  Will & Co is up there with the best of them!  One tip - They have Nitro Cold Brew which I hear is a big deal.  We didn't order it but if that's your thing you can find it here.

• Brittany P.

  star star star star star 14 May 2026

  Hands down the best everything! Food,atmosphere and service...we LOVED IT! Probably will be back everyday of our trip haha
  
  Day 2: HAD TO COME BACK! Was even better the second time around...CORN BREAD IS TO DIE FOR! Bacon is amazing! I'm also obsessed with there quiche and "Cinnsation" ice coffee was on point! I am ready to start my day and couldn't be happier. We have never been to Plymouth before but this will definitely not be our last trip, we are going to tell all our friends and family about this place! Thanks everyone working here for being so smiley and friendly, it goes a long way :)